International Women's Day – Cornton Vale Prison Protest

On 8 March, International Women’s Day comes around once more.

As the Scottish Socialist Voice explained in a previous IWD special (scroll down to centre pages):

For over 150 years, women and men across the world have demonstrated on International Women’s Day. On that day in 1857 in New York, hundreds of women workers in the textile industry went on strike, protesting casual labour, low wages and poor working conditions. The women were attacked and beaten by the police – their stand was one of the reasons 8 March was officially recognised as International Women’s Day in 1910. So why do we still mark the day now in the 21st century?

The multinational bank HSBC is a major sponsor of the ‘official’, or at least biggest, International Women’s Day celebrations in Britain now. Their website explains:
“Many companies have actively supported International Women’s Day… This is essential if they are to recruit and retain the best female talent, sell their products/services to them, and see more women investing in them.”
But for others, including the Scottish Socialist Women’s Network, the reasons we march on International Women’s Day are the same as why the New York textile workers marched – because we are still fighting low pay, exploitation and oppression.

Photo by Eva Merz

Socialists in Scotland will be marking the occasion with our annual International Women’s Day protest outside HMP Cornton Vale.

Cornton Vale is the only women’s prison in Scotland, and it is notoriously overcrowded – despite the fact that most of the inmates shouldn’t be there in the first place. Just one per cent of women in Cornton Vale are there because they have committed a violent offence. Previous reports have found that 90 per cent of women imprisoned in Scotland have committed crimes related to poverty  – through drug and alcohol abuse, non-payment of fines, or just struggling to cope with living below the breadline.

In 2006, it was found that 98% of the inmates were struggling with addiction; 80% had mental health problems and 75% were survivors of abuse.

Former Scottish Socialist Party MSP Rosie Kane was held in Cornton Vale in 2006 for non-payment of a fine. One of her fellow inmates was there for nothing more than throwing some candles and a James Blunt CD out of a window during an argument. You can read about Rosie’s experience in Cornton Vale here.

It costs £37,000 a year to keep one woman in Cornton Vale – that’s money that could be investing in helping women with drink and drug problems, helping poverty stricken women from having to turn to prostitution or theft to feed themselves, their families or their habits. That is money that could help women rebuilt their lives after abuse and trauma. Instead women are being locked up and mistreated over and over again.

Socialists and feminists protesting outside womens’ prisons is often misunderstood or deliberately misconstrued. We DON’T think women are inherently good and gentle and should therefore don’t belong in jail. The fact is that women receive disproportionately high sentences when compared to men who have committed similar crimes. As previously reported in Leftfield, shoplifters (mainly women) are more likely to be imprisoned than sex offenders (mainly men). Women taking a tiny bit of profit-making opportunity from private companies are considered more dangerous criminals than men who pose a serious risk to the safety of women and children. That’s FUCKED UP.

Stop the war on women!

Join us this Sunday, 7 March at 12 noon at Stirling Train Station, to march on Cornton Vale and PROTEST.

Please bring ribbons and flowers to decorate the fence.

If you are a driver, your help ferrying protesters from the train station to the prison would be much appreciated.

8 Comments

  1. Jack says:

    I’ll be going, providing I can find a way of getting there when I have a net monetary worth of zero.

  2. Eva Merz says:

    It’s good to see an article highlighting the issues of women in prison…. I work on a book project about women in prison, criminal justice and alternatives to imprisonment of women and girls who pose no risk to society, which takes its starting point in Cornton Vale… you can read about it here + find many interesting books, reports and articles about the issues: http://www.newsocialartschool.org

    To the Editor of this website i just wanna say, next time you borrow/steal an image from my website (above photo of CV is mine), make sure to ask first + credit – or at least link to where you found it. This is seriously bad style, Scottish socialist youth!

  3. Eva Merz says:

    btw i think protesting for women in prison is great, but outside cornton vale is a bit weird, since it’s not the people there you wanna convince, they totally agree that way too many women are being locked up. You should demonstrate at holyrood or in other public places where you find many people who need woken up about the facts…. However, i do think it’s great if your demo can give the women inside a bit of encouragement. Cheers!

  4. Sarah says:

    Hey, the main reason that we protest there is to give the women a bit of a lift and let them know that we’re thinking of them.

    This is something that Rosie Kane who spent a short time in Cornton Vale said:

    “Having spent time in Cornton Vale I can tell tou that every single woman I spoke to had been abused by at least one man in their difficult lives. Every woman on Bruce wing was on anti-depresants. Many young women were in there to detox because there were no available detox beds and they had committed minor crimes when under the influence. One woman was a seriously ill with mental health problems – she was also pregnant. She thought she was being guided by Prince William via an electrical system which had been placed in her spine. It was shocking however, the women in the main looked after each other, cared for the more vulnerable and were good at sharing their treats. I found them inspirational and have a wee prisoner bag to this day containing all my wee notes and gifts they gave me when I was liberated.

    Also in Bruce wing you spent most of the time in your cell locked in because their were staff shortages. I could go on, I guess I just want to wish you well and let you know the women love when we protest there. They are thrilled that we remember them and it gives them a real buzz and something to chat about. Good luck and well done – enjoy your day and know it is really important and worthwhile.”

  5. admin says:

    Hey Eva, I can edit the article to credit your photo, what website/page should I link to?

  6. Eva Merz says:

    Hey admin, thanks for getting back, credit me, Eva Merz – or just link to http://www.newsocialartschool.org (can you not remember where you found it?) ….

    cheers much…

    Exx

  7. admin says:

    I’ve edited the article with the link. It wasn’t me who originally wrote the article, so that’s why I wasn’t sure where to link to.

  8. LydiaTeapot says:

    Eva, we will always credit if the owner asks, but there really is no need to accuse us of stealing when there is no copyright on the actual picture and it can easily found on google images. Since the blog is non-profit and we didn’t edit and redistribute or try to claim ownership, there’s really no need to worry. It is a good picture though.