leftfield bumper competition: spot the lies!
Posted by Liam T in Uncategorized, tags: drugs, mephedrone, moral panic, science, tabloidsLeftfield would be the last blog to ever suggest that The Sun newspaper, as a bastion of journalistic integrity and proud defender of the truth, would ever stoop so low to tell lies on their front page. As such, we were utterly shocked and OUTRAGED today on our stroll to the shops to learn that not only is the government in the ‘GRIP’ of the unions (presumably the same union who’s action Gordon Brown described the other day as ‘unjustified and deplorable’) but that drugs are killing OUR CHILDREN! But hey look, a suspiciously free one pound bet!
Anyway, arriving home, I decided to do a little bit further investigation into this claim that ‘meow meow’, ie. the quasi-legal drug mephedrone (or bubbles, m-cat or ‘plant food’) ‘killed’ two teenagers.
While clearly absolutely tragic – two boys aged 18 and 19 collapsed and died on Monday following a night-out – what follows is less set-in-stone evidence that ‘drone lay behind their deaths, but more tabloid and police scaremongering and much stretching of the facts to suit their agenda that mephedrone = mega dangerous and needs banned straight away. Note also that the government’s Advisory Council on Drugs is expected to reach a decision on the drug within the next two weeks – if there was ever a time for ramping up the tabloid campaign to ‘BAN’ it, this is it.
In this vein, the article quotes Detective Chief Inspector Mark Oliver, who tells us that “We need to get the message across that this drug is dangerous and you may die if you take it”.
It seems that the specific circumstances of this case are slightly more complicated though – the Sun reports that “Officers believe both lads… also had access to heroin substitute methadone which they used to bring them down from the high of mephedrone.”
In other words, that mephedrone may have ’contributed to’ and been ‘linked to’ these deaths, is being taken and used by the Sun to mean that is absolutely, 100% lay behind them.
“It is not clear how the authorities know the drug is involved or whether the figure is the result of a single incident.”
And of course there is no argument from the Sun or the Government to scrap the methadone programme, which has failed to deal with heroin abuse.
Yay for Leftfield being the voice of scientific reason again! Me and Chelsea seen this on the news yesterday and both agreed it was bullshit. They might have drank some coffee that night too, don’t see the headline “COFFEE KILLS TWO TEENS” coming any time soon. It reminds me of the big panic when the HPV vaccine supposedly killed a girl, and it turned out to be totally unrelated, people just see connections that don’t exist everywhere.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_causation
I love this blog.
We love you Muzza.
I saw a clip on the news about this first “they took alcohol and mephedrone and methadone”. The next day it was “mephedrone killed them!!” all over the papers utterly ridicilous. One article I saw was demanding it be banned as it had a similar high to ectasy. I was under the impression that drugs were banned due to the “danger” they posed to users, not based on the high they gave. Maybe I was mistaken though, it would explain a lot…
Charlie Brooker’s colomn in the Guardian (which is always brilliant and worth a read):
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/mar/22/charlie-brooker-newspapers-dangerous-drug